
|
The Transmission of Trauma:
Psychoanalysis, Race, and Technologies
of Cultural Fantasy
Ph.D. Dissertation
Department of History of Consciousness
University of California, Santa Cruz
In The Transmission of Trauma, I draw
from the fields of trauma studies, psychoanalysis, and critical
race studies to theorize modes and effects of transmissions
of traumatic psychic material, focusing in particular on experiences
and representations of race and racism. The title of this
project borrows the concept of “technology” from
Michel Foucault’s notion of a “technology of sex”
in his History of Sexuality and Teresa de Lauretis’
Technologies of Gender. For Foucault and de Lauretis,
“technology” refers to a range of discourses,
ideologies, and cultural texts that circulate and instantiate
conventional notions of sex and gender. I take up the concept
of technology in The Transmission of Trauma to encapsulate
the networks of discourses and institutions that shape collective
understandings and experiences of race and racism as trauma.
I begin the first half of the dissertation with
a chapter entitled “Theorizing Cultural Fantasy: Sigmund
Freud, Nineteenth-Century Biology, and the Heredity of Traumatic
Experience.” In this chapter, I argue that Freud’s
psychoanalysis was particularly invested in explaining the
development of the psyche and the inheritance of psychical
material through the biological concepts of phylogeny (the
development of the species) and ontogeny (the development
of the individual). In chapter two of the dissertation, “The
Psychical Reality of Race: Cultural Trauma and Neurosis in
Frantz Fanon’s Black Skin, White Masks,”
I argue that colonial psychiatrist Frantz Fanon offers a prescient
analysis of the relationship between culture, racialization,
and trauma that builds on Freud’s pseudo-biological
theories of the inheritance of psychical material. Inventing
the concept of “sociogeny,” Fanon suggests that
racial stereotypes (more than biology or individual development)
structure the social subject’s quotidian experience
of racialization and racism. Thus he argues that any contact
with the culture of a racist society is psychically traumatic.
In this way, Fanon emphasizes that a theory of cultural (rather
than individual) trauma and fantasy in psychoanalysis is crucial
to understanding the very real, psychical effects of racism
on all social subjects.
I continue my exploration of the cultural transmission
of trauma in the second half of the dissertation by focusing
on two particular sites: Toni Morrison’s novel Paradise
(1998) and the notorious 1993 videotape of Los Angeles police
officers beating Rodney King. In chapter three, “The
Origins of Paradise: Race, Gender, and Cultural Fantasies,”
I contend that Morrison’s Paradise represents the effects
of the psychical trauma of racism through a depiction of fantasies
of racial purity and violence against women. Set in an all-black
town, and beginning with a description of nine men murdering
five women, Paradise explores the internal mechanisms
of racial fantasy and violence in black subjectivity in ways
that echo and move beyond Fanon’s Black Skin.
The cultural impact of racialized violence is also the subject
of chapter four, “Rodney King Is Being Beaten: Cultural
Fantasies and Spectacles of Violence,” where I analyze
the tape of police beating King as a site for examining the
psychical effects of dominant cultural fantasies of black
masculinity, violence, and subjection.
In each of these chapters, psychoanalytic theory
offers a methodology to account for the transmission of trauma
and for examining the traumatic effects of race and racism
in social subjects. This dissertation presents an argument
that contemporary scholars need not reproduce psychoanalysis
as an ahistorical, universalist paradigm. I contend that psychoanalysis
is a crucial site and apparatus for research on the histories
of science, colonialism, race, gender, sex, and sexuality.
|